The Iconography of Napoleon’s Stomach Ache


Contrary to what I have said earlier, and what many people actually think, the famous Napoleonic gesture has little to do with the Emperor’s stomach problems. This gesture has a very respectable classical provenance and descends from the statues to an Athenian orator and politician, Eschin. The gesture should be interpreted as a sign of Stoic reserve and profound contemplation. Its Neoclassical use in the portraits of Napoleon is due to a collaborative effort of a number of artists. The gesture is first suggested in the sketches of Jacques Louis David, who, as early as 1789, considers pressing General Bonaparte’s right arm against his chest to create some tension between action and apprehension; and already by 1801 a miniaturist, Jean-Baptiste Isabey, uses the magic formula by which the First Consul could be identified, even in the pictures that rend him unrecognizable. Isabey’s iconic formula is not immediately adopted, until Ingres makes the choice official by tucking Bonaparte’s left hand in, while using the right one for a pantomime gesture: Bonaparte was fond of his dainty little hands; and in the work of Ingres, unlike in that of Isabey, the right one is shown in all its splendor. And the belly…? As for the Emperor’s medical condition, his stomach ulcer manifested itself years later, when a copious but hasty meal could make His Imperial Majesty roll on the carpet in a rather undignified manner.



About versaillesgossip, before and after Francis Ponge

The author of the blogs Versailles Gossip and Before and After Francis Ponge, Vadim Bystritski lives and teaches in Brest France. The the three main themes of his literary endeavours are humor, the French Prose Poetry, the French XVII and XVIII Century Art and History. His writings and occasionally art has been published in a number of ezines (Eratio, Out of Nothing, Scars TV, etc). He also contributes to Pinterest where he comments on the artifiacts from the Louvre and other collections. Some of his shorter texts are in Spanish, Russian and French.
This entry was posted in Napoleon. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s